“Tragedy” in Flint


I grew up where water was cheap and easy. Living in a state surrounded by four Great Lakes is supposed to insure your water is always cheap and easy. And, you know, clean. And for the majority of my fellow Michiganders, this is the case. But obviously not everywhere.

People are calling the situation in Flint a ‘tragedy.’ As if chemical by-products, E. Coli, Legionnaire’s Disease and lead infiltration just dropped out of the sky, an apolitical tornado. Not to mention, this toxic water is on top of water prices that are about 3 times what they are everywhere else in the state.

It’s interesting to see what situations generate public outrage, and what situations are deemed to be “political footballs,” particularly amongst Christians. I hear people say “we can’t all be worked up all the time . . . different people care about different things.” And while that is true, it is hard to forget newsfeeds full of tri-colored flags and accusations of baby selling amidst the prevalent silence about Flint. What sparks our outrage and why? Why is it so easy to see someone’s humanity in one city, yet view them as merely a political pawn in another?

The situation in Paris didn’t happen in a vacuum. That was no less a political football than state and local politics, and yet most people didn’t think twice about sharing their outrage and grief. But just like the attacks in France have a long history going back at least a century, so too does the political and economic situation in Flint.

It is not an accident that Genesee County is 75% white and 20% black, while Flint is only 37% white and over 56% black. It is not an accident that the demographics of the suburbs of Flint are even worse, on average, 86% white and 8.6% black. This crisis in Flint is not an unexplained tragedy, and it is not something that will be fixed by water bottles of charity, as much as they are needed.

Water shouldn’t be a luxury and healthy living shouldn’t be a privilege. Wealthy white people don’t get to flee the cities for the suburbs, doing their damndest to keep people of color out along the way, and then wash their hands of the problems caused by their leaving.

Because it feels like the general sentiment is that if you happen to live in a poor city, you deserve what happens to you. You just need to pull on those bootstraps a little harder. Can’t afford to pay your bills? Then of course you get an Emergency Financial Manager. Constitutional rights, what are those? And if your expensive water makes you sick, well, come on. How bad can a little lead really be.

Who bears responsibility for poverty? Whose job is it to shoulder the heavy burden of high water bills and new infrastructure? And why should we care about the water now, when we never have before? (Why is the Flint River so polluted to begin with? *white shrug*) Whose job is it to care about this, anyway? Am I my brother’s keeper?

Christians do not have the option of being willfully ignorant or morally obtuse. Preaching about sins of the heart while avoiding sins of poverty and white flight is not an honest sermon. It is not a faithful interpretation of the life of Jesus, who I’m pretty sure said something about the purpose of his life being about setting the oppressed free.

What does it mean to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor in Flint?

What does it mean to over 100,000 people when we collectively shrug our shoulders at the devastation of their lives?

And if, as theologian Elsa Tamez says, God is on the side of the citizens of Flint, what does it say about our faith if we are not?

“Poverty is not a virtue but an evil that reflects the socioeconomic conditions of inequality in which people live . . . because of the insufferable conditions under which the poor live, God is obliged to fight at their side.” – Tamez, Bible of the Oppressed.

If being a “converted Christian,” to go old school here, means “thinking, feeling, and living as Christ,” then according to another theologian, Gustavo Gutiérrez, that necessarily means committing oneself “to the process of the liberation of the poor and oppressed.” ~ A Theology of Liberation

We can toss political footballs back and forth all day long, but how can we claim to walk in the footsteps of one breaking chains, when with our apathy and our votes, we bind them up?

Links to learn more:

A Toxic Timeline of Flint’s Water Fiasco

How Flint, Ferguson and Baltimore Are All Connected

Caris Adel
Latest posts by Caris Adel (see all)

7 thoughts on ““Tragedy” in Flint

  1. Perfect.

    I think there is something to be said when it comes to the “why isn’t THIS getting the outrage, the soundbites, the calls for SOMETHING HAS TO GIVE among Christians, when dishonestly edited videos purporting to show PP “selling baby parts” (since utterly disproved) did?”

    I think there’s something to be said about the difference between the saintly image of a perfect infant and the imperfect reality of the adults and children alive right now.

    I think there’s something to be said for the difference between the romance of flying to Africa or India or Central America and packing up a car to drive to the blistering cold of Michigan and hand out bottled water to a crowd of people who speak your language, having to acknowledge that the need here is just as desperate, that we are just as given to leaders who prioritize saving a few dollars per household over the lives of those living in those houses.

    I think there is something to be said for class – that we simply believe that misfortune befalls those who haven’t helped themselves, rather than our good fortune being largely an accident of where and when we were born.

    I think there is something HUGE to be said about race – that there’s a reason that the whiter cities of Michigan, even those dependent on auto manufacturing that has gone away – don’t fall prey to the same purposeful neglect that Flint did.

    I think there is something to be said about politics – people don’t want to think about how a Republican governor is the one who decided to railroad through Emergency Managers with no oversight and no one who cared whether they hurt the cities they were in charge of or not. It hurts the narrative of “Democrat governors failed michigan and got it where it is”. It hurts the division and forces us to pay attention to the fact that politics is just the color of your tie – terrible people find positions of power everywhere they can, no matter what politics they espouse.

    My heart breaks for the people of Flint – and for the previous mayor, who has gotten a lot of flack for constantly reassuring his town that the water was safe, only to have all of this come out and realize he’d spent a year lying to them without knowing it. He’s given a couple of interviews where he talks about coming to the realization that he had put so many children in danger because he believed what he was told by the Emergency Manager.

    SO many people should lose their jobs in this, or be put in prison. But it won’t help the children of Flint.

    “Emergency Management” is when you take a town and, in order to save $5 million, create an emergency that it will cost $400 million to manage.

  2. I shrugged my shoulders for so long over situations like this. Thank you, Caris, for being one of the people that helped me wake up to my own numb indifference.

  3. Caris, I loved this so much. The injustice can be so overwhelming we just shut down. It’s hard to engage in every news piece about the latest racist, classist, sexist uproar. Thank you for presenting this in such a profound and intelligent way.

  4. “Water shouldn’t be a luxury and healthy living shouldn’t be a privilege.” Oh, I totally agree with this and I wish there was something I could do. I feel so helpless and don’t know where to start, except to pray and hope that those who have authority will do what needs to be done. But I do think that right where we are we can try to make a difference by living as Jesus would have us to. I know I fail a lot, but I also know that God can and will wake us up. Thank you, Caris, for your voice!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.