The Stigma of Need

The first time it was suggested to me that I go on welfare I was 24-years-old. I had just left a job at a large non-profit (the kind you have to raise your own funds for) and started working part time again. I was used to part time work. I worked my way through college, often juggling 2-3 minimum wage jobs. “I got this.” I told myself, it didn’t seem like a big deal to be leaving my job.

The truth is I never received a full paycheck from that job. Like many minorities, I found the traditional method of supporting my salary through fundraising a challenge and was never fully funded. This time around, however, housing was also a struggle. I was no longer a student cramming into a small apartment with 3 other housemates to mitigate my cost of living. I needed to pay rent. But at minimum wage, affording an apartment in Minnesota wasn’t going to happen.

“You should apply for SNAP” my friend told me. Her suggestion made me pause. It had never occurred to me that I’d be eligible. If you’re unfamiliar with it, SNAP is a nutritional assistance program, more commonly known as food stamps. You’re not eligible as a student, so it hadn’t dawned on me that now I would qualify.

“Don’t worry about it, I’m fine.” I bristled before she could finish her suggestion. The truth is I was embarrassed she’d suggested it. Here I was with a degree, working over 40 hours a week and I still couldn’t support myself. I was already living out of her basement for the second time.  

On top of that, I know the stigma. I wasn’t going to fulfill the stereotypes others have of people of color on food stamps. I wasn’t going to be the welfare queen. I was told education was the golden ticket. Shouldn’t I be able to take care of myself now? As silly as it may sound I felt that applying for SNAP somehow negated all my degree represented. I already felt needy enough because I was unable to sustain my own housing.

My need exposed me. I had to face my own stigma around sufficiency, work and meritocracy. It wouldn’t be the first time. A few years later, I’ve found myself in this familiar place. I was laid off from my job last year. I’ve had to talk myself into taking unemployment and wrestle with the implications of it. It’s a conversation stopper when someone asks what you do and you tell them you’re unemployed.

Why is it that certain needs have stigma? We are so quick to rush judgement on those who receive disability, unemployment or SNAP. We don’t dare stigmatize those who participate in government programs like tax returns, the GI Bill, home buying incentives or educational credit. The stigma is around the way we define need. We want to hide our hearts from the truth that we are insufficient.

When I’m in these places of need I often hear well-worn verses and advice that are tainted with the notions that something will be fixed, changed or promised to me. I cannot count how many times I’ve been quoted Jeremiah 29:11. But I have learned by now that sometimes the heartache isn’t resolved. It doesn’t add up, and things are just hard. There will always be some sort of need–whether it be emotional, spiritual or physical.

I’m still asking: What does it mean that God says “I’ll supply all of your needs?” (Phil. 4:19) To be honest, these words often ring hollow to me. They don’t make sense. They get twisted in my heart and mind and sound distorted, like when a cassette gets eaten in a tape player. (Yes, I did just reference a cassette tape).

My heart jumps to extremes. My characterization of God ping-pongs between depravity and scarcity. It’s the prosperity gospel, I tell myself. Certainly, God doesn’t mean ALL my needs, that’s selfish, it’s materialism. I view God through a lens of stinginess, comparing my needs and life to everyone else’s.

When I’m in an unhealthy place, my needs set me apart– I’m single, underemployed and have unstable housing. I’ll gladly use this as ammunition against God. “Don’t you see my need?” I cry. I don’t understand why some of my basic needs (and desires) go unfulfilled.

But the truth is we all hold need. Mine just tend to be more obvious and external. It’s when I concede that the needs I have are sometimes irresolvable and inexplicable that God shows up. My confession becomes an entry point to a greater spiritual truth: The Kingdom of Heaven is found in recognizing my need (Matthew 5). God’s sufficiency is more about God’s presence than God’s actions.

Sufficiency means God doesn’t turn me away in my needy state. God listens. God hears. God sees. My situation may not change, but neither does God.

“Look at your own poverty

welcome it

cherish it

don’t be afraid

share your death

because thus you will share your love and your life” – Jean Vanier

Ruthie Johnson

3 thoughts on “The Stigma of Need

  1. My whole life There’s a squirrel in a cage up in my head rattling and I can’t rest!! I’ve got a lot of anxiety. I’ve got a lot of introjects telling me I’m not good enough, not lovable, not living up to their expectations even though they’re dead and buried long ago. I got into the 12-step program where they talk the talk and walk the walk. Us alcoholics are perfectionists!! My recovery began when I learn the importance of creating a gratitude list and started becoming honest with myself about my perfectionism. I can’t escape a lifelong habit completely but when I remember to live in the solution is when I can start my day over with
    intentional change of an attitude of gratitude!!

    • Isn’t it crazy how we pigeon hole ourselves with these expectations? Thanks for sharing and wishing you well in your journey of recovery! I have the highest respect for those who have gone through AA (I worked with a celebrate recovery group for a bit). I love the humility and resilience in the community!

  2. Oh girl, this is so good! I can’t tell you the shame I felt going on WIC and pregnancy medicaid with my babies. Same thing – I’d worked non-profit, had a degree, husband and I both worked hard – but we still needed help. It was a little easier to ask when it was for my kids. I would never let them go without. But still, such stigma. I got all the looks in the grocery store line. Every. time. And in three days I am unemployed. So many thoughts running through my head, so many lies. Thank you for helping us cling to truth as we confront the lies. May God open our eyes to the needs around us – and the way He supplies them, the way being vulnerable allows Him to work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.