Aftermaths of the Purity Movement

Sex, we were told, was bad.

We weren’t to have sex and we weren’t to express ourselves sexually. We weren’t to wear clothes that would make others think about sex, and we certainly weren’t supposed to think about sex ourselves. For sex, they told us over and over again, was a sacred act, a covenant that only found its truest expression in the marriage bed, for God really, truly only allowed sex to happen between a husband and wife.

So, we talked about it when we were allowed to talk about it, when our youth group leaders and Young Life leaders gave us permission and said it was okay.

Once a year, we gathered for the sex talk. We listened as our leaders – the married ones of the group, the adults whom we believed held authority over everyone else because they’d learned how to properly put to their reproductive organs to use – stood in front of the group, red-faced with embarrassment.

But we held sacred their words. We wore our rings and we promised to wait until marriage to do the act, to engage in The Sin that was surely the sin of sins – but wouldn’t be of the cardinal variety after we said the most sacred of words, “I do.” We were children of God, and our bodies, sacred vessels for God’s glory.

For ours was a culture of purity and of innocence, a tradition that kept sex hidden in the back closet of the spare bedroom, behind spider webs and dust mites and bins of forgotten clothing.

But then we left the safety of the sanctuary and put our trust on the altar of the jailed high school building.

After church on Sunday mornings and Wednesday nights, we went to learn, on Mondays and Thursdays and every other weekday in between. And it didn’t matter whether our schools were Christian or public or charter or whatever-else in between, sex was the unifying force of conversation.

We whispered about it with our girlfriends in the back of English class, and we scribbled every sordid detail in notes passed through locker doors. We shyly tucked our heads to our chests when he walked past us in the hallway, and we laughed loudly, robustly, haughtily when he ignored us. More than anything, we didn’t want him to think we weren’t strong, even if the way our bodies had met and mingled and danced together days before didn’t mean to him what it meant to us. So, laughter became the clothing we wore. Wide smiles masked our tears.

That was how we lived, caught between two worlds. To us, everything was black and white: sin and sacrament, lust and purity, shame and acceptance. We were either in or out, the good and bad our bodies performed the admission through Friday night or Sunday morning’s doors.

But God, it seemed, only lived inside one of those places – the room he inhabited perfect and pure and holy, without room for our dirty secrets. And when there wasn’t room for the things not seen by others, there wasn’t room for him to enter our hearts. And when he couldn’t enter our hearts because our exploits pushed him away, shame and regret and scandal became the hymns of our hearts, the only songs of worship we were allowed to sing.

Because a movement that started with the best of intentions – a movement toward purity, toward virginity, toward wholeness – oftentimes forgot to translate into a movement toward God.

So, when we did finally marry, some of us found more shame than freedom in sex. We didn’t know what to do with our bodies when we’d never let ourselves experience or feel or indulge in desire. We couldn’t see our bodies as good, as holy, as beautiful. Some of us didn’t know how to find God in the acts we’d long believed countercultural to holiness. Because if sex was bad, (for so had been pounded into our heads), what did this steaming act of desire have to do with the Creator? And some of us, of course, forgot about God altogether; when we opened the other door – the door of lust and desire, the door that gave way more to our bodies than to our promises – we believed we were also choosing to step away from the Holy One entirely. We knew we weren’t welcome in his presence anymore.

So now, with stretched and wrinkled and broken-down bodies, we sort through the stories of our youth. We seek to put together the pieces of a new puzzle, as we search for a narrative that might hold God and sex positively in the same sentence.

We ask for healing. We beg for wholeness. We lean into new visions of purity.

And we pray that someday, we might see ourselves and our bodies as good.

Cara Meredith

Writer at Be Mama Be
Cara Meredith is a writer, speaker and musician from the greater San Francisco area. She is passionate about theology and books, her family, meals around the table, and finding Beauty in the most unlikely of places. A seven on the Enneagram, she also can’t help but try to laugh and smile at the ordinary everyday.

Latest posts by Cara Meredith (see all)

  • I am a teen of this culture as well and an adult that struggles mightily to figure out the ways to translate it into something different as I get ready to discuss such things with my children. What I was told and what I believe are not the same and I want to spare them the confusion and struggle but it is hard to sort the two, isn’t it?

    • YES. How does this translate to our own children now …and additionally, can’t I just keep my babies my babies forever, so that I never have to have this conversation? (True story)

      • We’ve already talked about it with our 7 and 9 year olds. Figure earlier is better and they’ll come to us with questions. I’m trying to start those conversations and see sex as a normal part of life, because it is, not some taboo topic.

  • Karen Gonzalez

    This is the story of so many of my peers who married young. We were taught not to think or talk about sex in all the wrong ways but never how to see it rightly. Thanks for this thoughtful post. I know the intentions of the teachers of my youth were good but the results were still a skewed view of sex and sexuality.

    • Yes, the end result seems detrimental to so many of my peers from this generation. I didn’t even marry young, yet still feel rocked by its aftermath!

  • Tim

    When purity is not part of directing the focus on Jesus, then purity becomes an idol. It happens in even the best intentioned settings. Thanks for the corrective, Cara.

  • I also have peers who have struggled in their marriages because of how far we have gone as a church on the “sex is bad” rhetoric. We need to find a way to both lift up purity and commitment to one man, but also not make sex out to be evil and bad. Thanks for sharing!

    • Yes, what does it mean to find the balance and seek healing? Love your thoughts, Joanna!

  • I’ve been thinking about this, even though my girls are still so young. While I grew up in the purity culture, I never really embraced it to the extremes of shame–rebellion. But…. I also recognize that it wasn’t healthy. My husband hadn’t heard of this movement at all until we were talking about raising our future kids. But, his extreme isn’t the path we want to take, either. This is a rambling response, but you’ve giving me more to think about as we intentionally teach our girls about the beauty and care of sex.

  • Meghan Weyerbacher

    Amen, yes. Beautifully written, Cara!